Does Your Business Need a CFO? The Answer Isn’t As Simple As You Think

Hiring a Chief Financial Officer (CFO) isn’t like hiring a bookkeeper or a controller—it’s more like finding the right life partner. And, if you've ever been on a date, you know that what works for you might not work for someone else. And, vice versa. It's the same story here.

There is no one-size-fits-all CFO.

Some companies need a steady, reliable partner who brings structure, financial discipline, and long-term stability. Others need a high-energy strategist who thrives in the fast lane, helping a business scale rapidly and navigate complex financial waters.

The perfect CFO for one company might be a disaster for another. The key is finding the right CFO for your business stage, goals, and financial complexity.

Let’s break down:
✅ What makes a CFO the right fit
✅ The must-have hallmarks of a great CFO (no matter the company)
✅ Why not every business needs a full-time CFO—but every business needs strategic financial leadership


What Does a CFO Actually Do?

A CFO is not just an accountant with a fancier title. Their job isn’t just about tracking expenses or closing the books—it’s about strategy, risk management, and financial leadership.

A strong CFO will:

✔️ Develop and execute financial strategy that aligns with business goals
✔️ Ensure financial health through cash flow management, capital planning, and forecasting
✔️ Help secure funding—whether that’s bank loans, private equity, or investor capital
✔️ Optimize profitability through pricing strategies, cost management, and financial modeling
✔️ Provide financial clarity—translating complex numbers into actionable insights for the CEO


Let’s Rethink the “When Do You Need a CFO?” Question

In the past, people said, “Once you hit $XXM in revenue, you need a CFO.”

🚨 That’s a bad rule of thumb. 🚨

A $10M e-commerce company with straightforward operations and solid margins? Might not need a CFO.

A $5M manufacturer with complex contracts, financing needs, and international suppliers? Might need CFO-level support much sooner.

Instead of fixating on revenue as the trigger for hiring a CFO, we should be asking:

🔹 How complex are your financials?
🔹 Are you preparing for a major growth event (M&A, expansion, funding round)?
🔹 Are cash flow and working capital issues limiting your ability to scale?
🔹 Do you need financial strategy, but not every day?

For many small to mid sized companies, a full-time CFO isn’t necessary—but high-impact financial leadership is.

That’s where a hybrid approach makes sense:

💡 Hire the right finance professionals at the right level (like a Full Charge Bookkeeper, Controller, or Director of Finance).
💡 Bring in a Fractional CFO for strategic support as needed.


The Right CFO for Your Business Stage

🚀 Early-Stage Startups & Small Businesses ($1M–$10M Revenue)

You need a builder. A CFO who thrives in controlled chaos.

🔸 Scrappy, agile, and comfortable wearing multiple hats
🔸 Focuses on cash flow, funding strategies, and setting up financial systems
🔸 Handles pricing strategies, early-stage financial modeling, and investor relations
🔸 A fractional CFO is often ideal because a full-time hire is overkill

Think of this CFO as your first serious financial relationship—the one who helps lay the foundation.


📈 Growth-Stage Companies ($10M–$50M Revenue)

You need a stabilizer. A CFO who brings order to rapid expansion.

🔸 Financials get messy—more revenue, more complexity, and more risk
🔸 Implements structure, financial controls, and scalable processes
🔸 Helps with profitability, working capital management, and forecasting
🔸 Most companies at this level need a full-time Controller or Director of Finance and a Fractional CFO for strategic oversight

This CFO brings order to the chaos and helps the business mature.


🏛️ Established & Complex Companies ($50M+ Revenue)

You need a strategist. A CFO who optimizes long-term value and risk.

🔸 Leads M&A, corporate finance, and strategic planning
🔸 Focuses on investor relations, exit strategies, and risk management
🔸 Acts as a trusted advisor to the CEO and board

This CFO isn’t just keeping the books—they’re shaping the company’s financial destiny.


Breaking the Traditional CFO Model: Pay for What You Actually Need

💰 Let’s Talk About Cost

The reality is: Full Time CFOs are costly.

💵 Base Salary: $200K–$350K
💵 Bonus: 25%–50% of base salary
💵 Total All-In Employer Cost (Excluding Equity): ~$500K per year

For many small to mid sized companies, it may be difficult to recognize an acceptable return on this investment.

Here’s a better model:

💡 Employ a strong Full Charge Bookkeeper, Controller, or Director of Finance to manage the day-to-day
💡 Use a part time or fractional CFO for high-performance strategy and decision-making

You wouldn’t hire a master chef just to butter your toast. But when you're planning a gourmet dinner, you want someone who knows how to craft an unforgettable meal. You bring in the expert.


What Credentials & Experience Should a CFO Have?

🎓 Education & Certifications

✅ Bachelor’s degree in Finance, Accounting, or Economics (minimum)
Advanced Credentials (Highly Preferred):

  • CPA (Certified Public Accountant)
  • CMA (Certified Management Accountant)
  • CFA (Chartered Financial Analyst)
  • MBA (Master of Business Administration)

📈 Experience

✔️ Hands-on leadership in finance, not just reporting numbers but shaping business strategy
✔️ Direct involvement in capital raises, financial modeling, cost optimization, and forecasting
✔️ A track record of working with CEOs to align financials with business growth

🚩 Red Flags

❌ A CFO who only focuses on cutting costs but not growing revenue
❌ A CFO who is reactive instead of proactive
❌ A CFO who can’t simplify financial complexity for leadership


The Best CFO for Your Business Isn’t About Title—It’s About Fit

Hiring a CFO isn’t a box you check at a certain revenue milestone. It’s about:

✔️ What your business actually needs at its current stage
✔️ How much financial complexity you have
✔️ When strategic insight moves the needle for your growth

The modern finance model is shifting. High-growth companies don’t always need a full-time CFO—but they do need smart financial leadership.

That’s where fractional CFO services, outsourced finance teams, and scalable solutions come in.

Need the Right Financial Leadership? Let’s Talk.

At The William Stanley CFO Group, we know that every business has unique financial needs—and not every company requires a full-time CFO. Whether you're looking to build a strong financial foundation, optimize your operations, or navigate complex strategic decisions, we provide the right level of expertise at the right time.

If you’re wondering what kind of financial leadership your business actually needs—let’s talk.

📩 Contact The William Stanley CFO Group today to explore how fractional CFO services, strategic advisory, or financial oversight can help your business grow—without the burden of unnecessary overhead.

Your business deserves the right financial strategy, at the right time, with the right expertise.

Contact Us

We’d love to hear from you so we can provide you with an experienced CFO perspective you can trust. Fill out the form or give us a call at (813) 710-9327. We’ll be in touch with you shortly to discuss your business needs.

    Tampa Bay Chamber Small Business of the Year Winner Startup

    1315 S Howard Ave Suite 201,
    Tampa, FL 33606
    (813) 710-9327

    Email:
    [email protected]

    © 2024 The William Stanley CFO Group. All rights reserved.
    linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram